Image Credit: SelinaB / GamifiedLife, LLC

New Fish to Catch

Goofy loves to fish, as you know. So, it’s no surprise that you soon see him wondering around Disney Dreamlight Valley’s Eternity Isle with his fishing pole over his shoulder. Odd, though. Goofy seems a bit out of sorts. He seems to have caught a lot of fish. Perhaps he’s frustrated about the ones that got away. Best go and check on him!

Fishing on Eternity Isle

Eternity Isle holds a whole new variety of fish to catch.

It doesn’t take long before Goofy, Disney Dreamlight Valley’s Angler Extraordinaire, arrives to cast his line. You’re anxious to see what he thinks about all the strange and interesting new fish.

Quest Task: Goofy must be fascinated by all the strange new fish around Eternity Isle

  • Talk to Goofy

Image Credit: IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

Can’t Catch Me

Goofy starts fishing at The Docks, but fishing on Eternity Isle holds a particularly difficult challenge for Goofy. The fish are not cooperating.

With a little encouragement, Goofy shares his tales of the fish that got away.

Hopefully, your luck is better. Head out to try to catch the elusive fish.

Quest Task: Catch some of the strange new fish around the Isle.

  • Dunebopper – 2
  • Robot Fish – 2
  • Prisma Shrimp – 2

Pro Tip: For help in finding your way around, see our Navigating Eternity Isle Guide.

Image Credit: IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

Finding The Ones That Got Away

Looking for the fish that got away from Goofy? Here’s where you’ll find them.

Robot Fish

  • Location: The Docks & The Overlook (Ancient’s Landing)
  • Fishing Circle: Red

Prisma Shrimp

  • Location: The Grove (Wild Tangle)
  • Fishing Circle: Red

Dunebopper

  • Location: The Oasis (Glittering Dunes)
  • Fishing Circle: Blue

How to Reach the Fishing Spots

Entering the Overlook in Ancient’s Landing will require some Mist. Getting to The Oasis and The Grove requires both Mist and the completion of a few quests.

Here is a comprehensive list of what you need to do

Three of the areas are originally blocked. Once you have completed the quests where you retrieve the Royal Hourglass, and have gathered some Mist, you have the means to enter them all.

Approach the blocked entrance to each area and Merlin will be on hand to help you with the rest.

Cost of Entry

  • The Overlook in Ancient’s Landing – 6000 Mist
  • The Grove (Wild Tangle) – 4000 Mist
  • The Oasis (Glittering Dunes) – 6000 Mist

Quests Needed to Open Glittering Dunes & Wild Tangle

It’s a great day for a little fishing!

Image Credit: IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

The Catch of the Day

With the days catch in hand, you show them all to Goofy. He’s excited that you caught every single fish that was giving him trouble. And now, he’s looking forward a good meal!

While you were fishing, Goofy gathered some ingredients to use in your fish recipes. He has a whole crate of things to give you. Good deal!!

Quest Task: Gather some of the strange new fish around the Island for Goofy:

  • Dunebopper – 1
  • Robot Fish – 1
  • Prisma Shrimp – 1

Quest Task: Bring everything you caught to Goofy.

Image Credit: IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

Remy’s Recipe Assistance

Now you just need to figure out a good recipe for these strange new fish.

Remy is the best source for information on recipes. You head off to find him. He’s sure to have some good suggestions!

Pro Tip: When you talk to Remy, answer “I think I’ll experiment with some other Ingredients…” after he provides recipe suggestions and he’ll continue talking. When he’s done, you’ll have information for a recipe for all three fish. Be sure to write it down (or look at the pictures below).

Nuts and Bolts

Image Credit:IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

Blend of the Bayou

Image Credit: IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

Sand Stew

Image Credit:IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

A Meal of Fish

What you decide to cook with the new fish, is totally up to you. Remy provides a few suggestions, but there may even be more to try.

With the ingredients that Goofy provided, the meal will be ready in no time.

Quest Task: Cook any meal using the Dunebopper, Robot Fish, or Prisma Shrimp.

Image Credit: IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

Compare Meals

Goofy tried his hand at creating a meal with the new fish as well. You meet to compare notes and share your meals. Goofy’s contribution was a bit unexpected, but good none-the-less!

What a great end to a day of fishing. A good meal with a good friend!

Quest Task: Tell Goofy about the meal you made.

Image Credit: IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

More Eternity Isle Adventures Await

Previous Quest

Image Credit:IzziBGran / GamifiedLife, LLC

Scrooge Quest

Image Credit: SelinaB / GamifiedLife, LLC

For more Eternity Isle fun, check out: A Garden in the Desert.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

About the Author: IzziBGran

IzziBGran started gaming in her mid-twenties, and it quickly became one of her favorite pastimes. Currently her favorite games include Disney Dreamlight Valley, Dragon Quest Builders II, and Zelda Tears of the Kingdom but she dabbles in other RPGs regularly. When she retired, she became a curator for GamifiedLife to add some additional excitement to her gaming life.

Get the latest news & updates

Subscribe to Our Newsletter